![spacer graphic]()  | 
      | 
      | 
      PALM BEACH COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD SPEC MTG BARGAINING UNIT APPR. 
      MINUTES 
      Special Meeting/Workshop 
       
        - Convene: 3:25 p.m.
  
        - Public Comments: None
  
        - Adoption of Bargained Health Insurance Provisions
  
         Motions: 
        
          
          
            | I recommend that the Board approve the Contract 
              amendments on Health Insurance with the Association of Educational 
              Secretaries and Office Professionals, the National Conference of 
              Firemen & Oilers, and the Police Benevolent Association for 
              calendar years 2007 and 2008; and pending ratification of the 
              Classroom Teachers Association, approve the Contract amendments on 
              Health Insurance with the Classroom Teachers Association for 
              calendar years 2007 and 2008. | 
            - | 
            PASS |  
          
            | Minutes: Adoption of health insurance provisions of the 
              collective bargaining agreements between The School Board and The 
              Association of Educational Secretaries and office Professionals 
              (AESOP), The Classroom Teachers Association (CTA), The National 
              Conference of Fireman & Oilers (NCF&O), and The Police 
              Benevolent Association (PBA). |  
          
            | Vote Results: |  
          
            |   Motion: Debra Robinson |  
          
            |   Second: Mark Hansen |  
          
            |   Sandra Richmond | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Paulette Burdick | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Monroe Benaim | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Mark Hansen | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Debra Robinson | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Bill Graham | 
            - | 
            Aye |    
        - APPROVAL OF THE BENEFITS RECOMMENDED FOR EMPLOYEES NOT REPRESENTED 
        BY A BARGAINING UNIT
   Motions: 
        
          
          
            |   I recommend the School Board approve the 
              medical benefits plan for employees not represented by a 
              bargaining unit for a two–year period of January 1, 2007 through 
              December 31, 2008. | 
            - | 
            PASS |  
          
            | Minutes: The premiums and plan design will be aligned 
              with those for employees in the various bargaining groups. For 
              2007: Employees who enroll in HMO or EPO will not pay any increase 
              in premium. The District contribution towards the POS and PPO plan 
              will be the same as the contribution towards the HMO Employee 
              contribution for POS and PPO plans coverage has increased and is 
              reflected on the attachment. Employees who choose single HMO 
              coverage will continue to receive Benefit dollars, ($20 per month 
              HMO and $60 per month EPO), which may be used for other benefits. 
              Full time employees who waive health insurance and attest to other 
              coverage, will continue to receive $120 a month ($90.00 for part 
              time employees) to spend on other benefit choices. Employees will 
              continue to receive EAP benefits and $20,000 of basic term life 
              and be able to purchase higher amounts of term life through 
              payroll deduction. For 2008 · A predetermined increase 
              contribution by employees towards HMO & EPO dependent coverage 
              has been agreed to and is reflected on the attached sheet. · The 
              $20 benefit dollar credit will be eliminated for those employees 
              enrolling in the employee only HMO and reduced to $40.00 per month 
              for those in the employee only EPO. All benefit dollars will be 
              deposited into a 401a) account for the employee.  |  
          
            | Vote Results: |  
          
            |   Motion: Mark Hansen |  
          
            |   Second: Debra Robinson |  
          
            |   Sandra Richmond | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Paulette Burdick | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Monroe Benaim | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Mark Hansen | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Debra Robinson | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Bill Graham | 
            - | 
            Aye |    
        - UNITED HEALTHCARE CONTRACT
   Motions: 
        
          
          
            | I recommend the Board approve the contract with 
              United Health Care to act as a servicing agent to administer the 
              District’s employee medical plan for a three year period from 
              1/1/2007 through 12/31/2009. | 
            - | 
            PASS |  
          
            | Minutes: United Healthcare has been the District’s 
              Medical Care Provider since 1/1/1997 and has a mostly positive 
              reputation with employees. United will administer all claims and 
              provide the same services and reports we received when fully 
              insured for a $21.50 per employee per month administration fee, 
              which is guaranteed for a period of three years. United will 
              continue to fund $200,000 annually to support Wellness and other 
              enrollment costs. We recommend purchasing individual stop loss 
              insurance for total claims on any individual that exceeds $500,000 
              with no maximum for a $4.95 per employee per month premium. The 
              total per employee per month fee would be $21.50 + $4.95 for a 
              total of $26.45 or an annualized fee of $6,665,400 based on 21,000 
              employees. Our benefits consultant, Edify, has marketed the excess 
              insurance and negotiated comparable rates with United HealthCare. 
              We recommend leaving the specific excess with United Health Care 
              for at least the first year to keep a total interest in the plan. 
              Also, reimbursement waiting periods are eliminated. A group of 
              21,000 employees is statistically valid and should not see wide 
              variations in claims. Therefore, we believe the only difference 
              between fully insured vs. self insured is the premium tax and risk 
              margin the carrier would charge if fully insured. An actuarial 
              report by an independent actuary will be conducted by APEX 
              Management Group for compliance with FS 112.08 filing requirements 
              to certify the plans soundness. The District will continue to fund 
              this plan utilizing the fully insured premiums proposed by United 
              HealthCare which is 3.8% above 2006 premiums. All claim payments, 
              administration fees, and specific stop loss premiums will be paid 
              from these funds. Performance Guarantees as well as in-network 
              discount guarantees have been negotiated. We were able to 
              negotiate a flat 3-year servicing fee. This is a recommendation to 
              approve a 3-year servicing contract; however, we have a clause 
              which allows cancellation by The School District at the end of 
              each year. Our consultant, Edify, has thoroughly reviewed this 
              plan and fully supported this proposal. |  
          
            | Vote Results: |  
          
            |   Motion: Mark Hansen |  
          
            |   Second: Debra Robinson |  
          
            |   Sandra Richmond | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Paulette Burdick | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Monroe Benaim | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Mark Hansen | 
            - | 
            Aye |  
          
            |   Debra Robinson | 
            - | 
            Not Present |  
          
            |   Bill Graham | 
            - | 
            Aye |    
        - Adjourn: 3:45 p.m.
   
      
      
          | 
      | 
      |